Decision Points · a statistics mini case study

Whose performance is stronger?

What you’re working out: how to compare two performances from two different events.

A pair of track spikes at one end of a table, a swim cap with goggles resting on it at the other, and one medal on a ribbon lying between them.

Your college names one Athlete of the Week, and this week it’s down to two women. Leah ran the 100-meter dash in 11.45 seconds. Maya swam the 100-yard freestyle in 48.08 seconds.

They never raced each other. So the committee compares each one with the women she actually raced.

Two races, one picture

Every dot is one woman’s time, the 77 sprinters on top and the 81 swimmers below. In each row, the dashed line is that field’s mean, and the axis counts seconds from it, faster to the left.

Sprinters: mean 12.278 seconds, standard deviation 0.413 seconds.

Swimmers: mean 50.059 seconds, standard deviation 1.994 seconds.

Leah beat her field’s mean by about 0.8 second. Maya beat hers by about 2 seconds. And look how the sprinters are bunched together, while the swimmers are spread wide.

So whose performance is stronger, compared with the women each one raced?