You rent a one-bedroom apartment near campus for $1,500 a month, and your lease renewal letter just came. Starting in August, your rent goes up to $1,650, which is $150 more each month.
The letter says the increase is because rents in the area have risen sharply, and it includes a bar graph as evidence. Before you sign, check whether the graph shows that your raise is in line with the market.
“Due to rising rents in our area, your monthly rent will increase to $1,650 when your new lease begins on August 1. The enclosed graph shows how sharply rents in our area have risen.”
The letter’s graph
It shows the average rent for a one-bedroom apartment in the area, not your own rent, with one bar for each year from 2020 through 2025 and dollars up the side.
Each bar has its amount printed on top: the 2020 bar says $1,400, and the 2025 bar says $1,540.
The 2025 bar is 8 times as long as the 2020 bar.
How much did the area’s average rent go up from 2020 to 2025?
You said it went up a lot.
No. The bars make the rise look large: the 2025 bar is 8 times as long as the 2020 bar.
But the average rent went from $1,400 to $1,540, up only $140, and $1,540 is just 1.1 times $1,400. So the bars disagree with the rents printed on them.
You said it went up only a little.
That’s right. The bars make the rise look large: the 2025 bar is 8 times as long as the 2020 bar.
But the average rent went from $1,400 to $1,540, up only $140, and $1,540 is just 1.1 times $1,400. So the bars disagree with the rents printed on them.
You weren’t sure.
That’s fine. The bars make the rise look large: the 2025 bar is 8 times as long as the 2020 bar.
But the average rent went from $1,400 to $1,540, up only $140, and $1,540 is just 1.1 times $1,400. So the bars disagree with the rents printed on them.
Why the bars disagree
The reason is the baseline, the value corresponding to the bottom of the bars. On the letter’s graph, the baseline is $1,380, not zero.
Here is the same graph again, with the same rents, but this time you can move its baseline.
The readout below tells how many times as long the 2025 bar is as the 2020 bar. Use the slider to move the baseline down to zero, and watch how the two bars compare.
With the baseline at zero, the length of each bar is the whole rent, so comparing the lengths compares the rents, and the 2025 bar is 1.1 times as long as the 2020 bar.
With the letter’s baseline at $1,380, each bar showed only the part of its rent above $1,380: $20 for 2020 and $160 for 2025. That exaggerated the differences between the bars.
The rents printed on the bars never changed. Only the baseline changed.
What it adds up to
Does the letter’s graph show that your raise is in line with the market? No. Redrawn from zero, its bars show the area’s average rent going up $140 over 5 years.
Your rent is going up $150 all at once, more than the area’s average went up in all 5 years.
When a graph or plot represents how much or how many of something, check the baseline. If it isn’t at zero, the graph may be misleading.
