Decision Points · a statistics mini case study

You tested positive. How worried?

What you’re working out: what a positive result on a screening test tells you.

Ines, a young woman with curly hair, sits at a small kitchen table in morning light and looks toward the window, her phone face up with its screen off on the table beside a mug.

Ines is a sophomore at Kettle State. During orientation, the campus health center offered a free screening for a condition that 1 in 100 students have, usually without knowing it.

The pamphlet says the test is right 90% of the time, for students who have the condition and for students who don’t. This morning, Ines’s result came back positive. How worried should Ines be?

1,000 students

Each mark is one student at the screening. The 10 circles are the students who have the condition, 1 in 100. The 990 squares are the students who don’t.

Has the conditionDoesn’t have it

Nobody has been tested yet.

With a positive result, how likely is it that Ines has the condition?