Picture the end of a job hunt, with two offers on the table: the same role, in the same town, at the same starting pay.
What you’re weighing is where the job leads. Neither firm will say what anyone earns. Each gives you one figure: the mean salary of the 11 people on the team you’d join.
Two means
The scale is salary, from $0 to $100,000 a year. Brightwell’s row is on top, with its mean marked at $86,000. Stonebridge’s mean, on the row below, is $71,000.
Brightwell’s is $15,000 higher.
Which offer would you take?
You’d take Brightwell’s.
That’s the usual pick: its mean is higher. A mean squeezes 11 salaries into one number, and one number can’t show you the 11 behind it. Suppose you could see them all.
You’d take Stonebridge’s.
That goes against the means. A mean squeezes 11 salaries into one number, and one number can’t show you the 11 behind it. Suppose you could see them all.
You said you’re not sure.
That’s fair. A mean squeezes 11 salaries into one number, and one number can’t show you the 11 behind it. Suppose you could see them all.
Every salary
Here they are, one dot per person, on the same salary scale, from $0 to $100,000 a year. Brightwell’s row is still on top, and each firm’s mean is marked on its row.
Stonebridge’s 11 run from $59,000 to $84,000. Brightwell’s salaries run from $40,000 to $72,000, except one.
That one is far larger than all the rest: the founder’s salary, $396,000. That salary is an extreme value, so far out that it sits off the scale, past its right end.
See where Brightwell’s mean lands without the founder: press Founder out.
Without the founder’s salary, Brightwell’s mean drops from $86,000 to $55,000, less than every salary at Stonebridge. That one salary had pulled Brightwell’s mean above every other salary at Brightwell.
So the mean is not a resistant statistic: one extreme value can affect it a lot. And 6 of Brightwell’s other 10 are paid less than anyone at Stonebridge.
What it adds up to
So which offer would you take now? That’s your call, but the means hid what matters: most people at Stonebridge are paid more than most people at Brightwell.
The medians say so: $56,000 at Brightwell and $69,000 at Stonebridge. The median is resistant: without the founder’s extreme value, Brightwell’s median moves only to $54,000.
The mean is not resistant, so when someone hands you a mean, ask for the median too, to get a fuller picture.
