Decision Points · a statistics mini case study

Will you make it to class?

What you’re working out: which of two routes gives you the higher probability of making it to class on time, when both routes have the same mean.

A student with a backpack steps out of a front door onto a sunny street, keys in hand, heading off for the day.

You have two ways to get to class, and you’ve taken each one often enough to know how it behaves. On both routes, your times from door to seat are normally distributed, with a mean of 20 minutes.

Route A is steady, with a standard deviation of 2.5 minutes. Route B is erratic, with a standard deviation of 5 minutes.

You make it to class if your trip is shorter than the time you have before class starts.

The morning you left early

You have 25 minutes, 5 more than the mean.

The picture has a row for each route, Route A on top, on one scale of minutes from door to seat, from 5 to 35, with shorter trips to the left.

Each curve is a normal curve. Route A’s is tall and narrow, because its times stay close to the mean. Route B’s is wide and flat, because its times are more spread out.

The dashed line is at 25 minutes. Every trip to the left of it gets you there in time, so the shaded area to the left of the line is the probability that you make it.

On Route A, that area is 0.9772. On Route B, it’s 0.8413.

So the steady route is more likely to get you there in time. Route B’s slow mornings spill past the line, and Route A’s rarely do.

Another morning, you oversleep and have only 15 minutes. Which route gives you the higher probability of making it?